Pretty much the most interesting blog on the Internet.— Prof. Steven Landsburg

Once you get past the title, and the subtitle, and the equations, and the foreign quotes, and the computer code, and the various hapax legomena, a solid 50% English content!—The Proprietor

Showing posts with label Immigration. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Immigration. Show all posts

Saturday, October 3, 2015

The Good News from Twentieth Century History

Evangelion

Being free; being rich; being secure from external enemies—these are all very good things. The great good news of twentieth century history is that these are not independent goods between which one might have to choose. Rather they flow from each other and mutually support each other in virtuous circles. So one could have reasoned from first premises: freedom leads to capitalism; capitalism leads to wealth; and wealth can be turned to military might, when the need arises. But each one of these steps is sufficiently contingent and uncertain that one might harbor reasonable doubts that conclusion always obtains but for the evidence of the great conflicts of the twentieth century which confirms that—at least at the current stage of technological and social development—it always holds.

Wednesday, September 30, 2015

The Current U.S. Immigration System Is the Best That Can Be Hoped For

The titular proposition, not endorsed by any politician or commentator the author is aware of,The closest parallel are some remarks unsurprisingly by Milton Friedman: Now, that Mexican immigration, over the border, is a good thing. It’s a good thing for the illegal immigrants. It’s a good thing for the United States. It’s a good thing for the citizens of the country. But, it’s only good so long as its illegal. is a peculiar one to be advanced here for reasons both personal and principled.

How to Easily and Cheaply Stop and Reverse Illegal Immigration

illegal immigrants

Exchanges may be mutually beneficial and yet never occur because of the Prisoner’s Dilemma. If one party can costlessly renege on its promises after the other party has performed, the observed equilibrium will often be universal defection without any mutually beneficial cooperation. One of the greatest benefits of laws and courts is that there mere potential of suing for breach of contract is enough to move us to the cooperative equilibrium without even requiring very many such suits.

Monday, August 17, 2015

How to Cut Taxes When Congress Won't

Imagine a 2017 with a newly sworn-in President Paul (or Cruz), but a Congress no more and perhaps less conservative than the current one.

The President announces as one of his main legislative priorities a comprehensive reform of the tax system, including reducing the top marginal individual federal income tax rate from the current 44% or so to 25%. However, after extensive debates accompanied by great acrimony and perhaps a filibuster or two, Congress refuses to enact the President's tax reform.

Thursday, May 13, 2010

Weak Arguments Against Illegal Immigration (Part 1 of Possibly Many)

Last week, I asked Prof. Landsburg (who was so kind today as to repost my Al Gore post) to respond to some of the less silly arguments against large scale immigration, rather than just making fun of some of the sillier ones, and the good professor graciously responded in comments on his blog and while I have one or two thoughts in reply, none are urgent, earth-shattering, or sufficiently well steeped in reflection that the world could not wait for them another day.

Instead let me take the opportunity to seriously respond to one of the weaker yet popular arguments against the current wave of low-skill large-scale immigration bandied about today, to wit: That most of it is contrary to the laws of the United States. It usually takes the form of rhetorical questions like "What part of 'illegal' don't you understand?" and is frequently considered by its advocates an irrefutable argument ender.

Yet it is hardly that as a little further thought demonstrates. But first to give its advocates their due:

First, in so far as they merely stress the illegality in protest against the common media euphemism "undocumented worker"—as if any non-trivial number of these had just misplaced their legal work authorizations, rather than working and living in the United States in violation of the law, i.e., illegally—or the equally odious media practice of equating opponents of illegal immigration as "opponents of immigration"—while slyly hinting that this renders them hypocrites as immigrants or descendants of immigrants themselves—their ire at much reporting is not misdirected. But that of course is not the fault of the actual illegal immigrants and hardly settles what would be a just way of dealing with them.

Second, a strong social norm in favor of legal conduct is probably a necessary (but not sufficient) condition for the continued existence of liberal, open society—that is one, in which most people most of the time are free to do as they please for their own reasons and without governmental surveillance. As a lawyer and a blogger who just denounced two scholars for completely ignoring legality in their arguments about the propriety of strategic mortgage default, I would be a hypocrite to argue otherwise.

That said, the fact that many immigrants are illegal does not settle the questions (1) of whether they ought to be and, even if they ought to be, (2) how severe a punishment can or should be imposed on them consistent with either economic efficiency or our moral sentiments.

First, whether a particular immigrant is illegal depends on the whim of Congress; whether he or she ought to be depends on moral and economic reasoning. The faint hope that there is some sort of relationship between the two survives, but obviously it is not perfect. Some laws—imagine a law requiring people born on odd days of the month to murder and take the property of their neighbors born on even days—are so wrong that it would be profoundly wrong to obey and absolutely require breaking. Some laws—think of import restrictions and tariffs to protect special interests like steel manufacturers—are wrong to a lesser degree, so that one may obey out of prudence or, if you will, cowardice and yet would cheer their violators—as this author would any brave steel smuggler! To derive, with mathematical certainty, that certain immigrants should be illegal because they are is to commit a specialized form of the naturalistic fallacy: deriving an ought from an is.

As far as laws are concerned, the reverse is the sound policy: We ought to make illegal what is already morally wrong or economically inefficient for other reasons, rather than argue that something is morally wrong on the sole basis that it is illegal. In the case of most illegal immigrants—who commit no other crimes, work hard at less than desirable jobs, use their income to take care of their families, and aside from distributional issues on net undoubtedly improve the welfare of other residents of this country—it is very hard to argue that what they are doing is inherently morally wrong or an economic harm. One suspects that is why their opponents fall back on the illegality argument so often.1

Second, while as conceded above, a social norm for obeying all but the most odious laws (like those requiring murder or economic tariffs) is a good thing, it hardly follows that we must punish illegal immigrants as severely for their violation as most proponents of enforcement demand. Let's be clear: the punishment for an illegal immigrant who is brought to the attention of the right federal (and many state) authorities, even if it is a first offense and there are no other allegations of criminality, is draconian: deportation. That means loss of job and home, drastic reduction in standard of living, permanent separation from friends, and in many cases family. That is a pretty harsh penalty.

Now many would respond, "but they broke the law, so they earned their punishment!" But again this is hardly a sufficient argument. Even setting aside the fact that the U.S. is at risk of drowning in useless laws whose violation is nearly as unavoidable as breathing, even generally good and wise laws are frequently broken without justifying such harsh penalties. Or at least, I've never known any adult who claimed to have never violated the speed limit by so much as one mile per hour or have jay walked. Even if one believes that these are violations of appropriate law, it seems indisputable that their universal and strict enforcement would bring the nation to a standstill. Punishing violators as harshly as violators of the immigration laws would depopulate it.

So, even if—contrary to what my opinion as argued above—laws prohibiting many immigrants from entering and working in the U.S. were proper, the punishment would hardly fit the crime. In particular, for first time offenders, the laws are massively more lenient towards car thieves, muggers, burglars, and those guilty of simple assault, even though the offenders are indisputably far more morally culpable (and their conduct economically harmful).2

So if deportation, either juridically or self- (in order to avoid the juridical alternative), is excessively harsh punishment for illegal immigrants, what is the alternative? The only one possible seems to be legalization, perhaps combined with some level of lesser punishment such as a fine or permanently ineligibility for citizenship. That may not exactly fit the legal definition of amnesty (that is, the complete forgiveness of a legal offense), but will likely be close enough to deserve that title.

1A similar argument is often made against those who favor abolition of the current law against recreational drugs. "What part of 'illegal' don't you understand?" "If you think that will reduce crime, why not just legalize murder, that would reduce crime too, huh?" The flaw is the same: We ought to make illegal what is already wrong for extra-legal reasons. The arguments for the immorality and economic inefficiency of murder are already pretty strong without any reference to its illegality. Murder should be illegal because its wrong; it is not seriously wrong just because it is illegal. The drug prohibition and the severe restrictions on immigration in current law cannot make the same claim.

2In fact, this author might be convinced to support deportation for many of those offenders!

Thursday, May 6, 2010

Non-Stupid Arguments against Large-Scale Low-Skill Immigration

Steve Landsburg has a great deal of fun with insulting some of the more stupid immigration restrictionists. Having long been an admirer of the good professor and read—usually with agreement, but always with pleasure and enlightenment—all of his writings online and off- that I've been able to lay my hands on, it might seem churlish of me to ask him to lay off and consider another target instead. Also, there is a certain entertainment value in watching a battle of wits between an unarmed man and a bazooka wielder.

Yet, I would ask Prof. Landsburg to turn his attention to some of the less stupid and potentially more damaging, at least with respect to an intelligent audience, objections to large-scale, low-skill immigration of the type observed by the United States over recent decades. For example:

  1. Under standard and generally reasonable microeconomic assumptions, added supply of low-skill immigrant labor will etceteris paribus tend to lower the price of its substitutes, in this case native low-skill labor. The standard, correct response is that competition is not an externality or legal tort: Any losses to native low-skill labor will be more than made up by the gains to employers of low-skill labor and the low-skill immigrants.

    But is this response likely to be acceptable the electorate (which includes many more low-skill laborers than their employers) and their political representatives? Or will they respond by other counter-productive measures such as increased income redistribution? Will those likely responses be more or less harmful, economically or ethically, than enforced immigration restrictions?

  2. Relatedly but separately, many of these low-skill immigrants will eventually become low-skill citizens and voters. If their voting patterns are anything like that observed of other low-skill voters, the electoral and hence policy and hence economic consequences would be likely be what I (and perhaps Prof. Landsburg) would consider catastrophic. Again: Will those likely harms outweigh, economically or ethically, those of enforced immigration restrictions?

Again—not being a sea cucumber—I agree with what I perceive to be Prof. Landsburg's support for open immigration. In an ideal world, I'd do so unreservedly. In the real world, I do so reservedly for the reasons mentioned above.

Prof. Landsburg: while of course you do not owe me any response, I'd be sincerely curious to know what your responses would be.